Halting the juggernaut – Frontline
In November, solely a few weeks earlier than polling for the Meeting election in Madhya Pradesh, Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan informed The Hindu, “Individuals sitting in Delhi discuss issues like anti-incumbency. Come to Madhya Pradesh and you will see there’s solely pro-incumbency for the BJP.” He was proper. The election consequence within the State, introduced on December 3, was historic for a number of causes, but it surely first confirmed how the BJP had turn out to be such a formidable election machine. Many pundits scoffed on the thought that the BJP would return to energy after ruling the State for nearly 20 years, however the get together proved the naysayers mistaken by registering a win that was by all accounts “huge”. Madhya Pradesh has now been added to the checklist of States—Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat—the place the BJP is dominant and onerous to problem.
The shock win in Chhattisgarh solely strengthened the BJP’s grip over the Hindi heartland—the north and west of India. The States on this belt are all essential to the 2024 Lok Sabha election. Up north, the Congress is in energy solely in Himachal Pradesh. The best way issues have stacked up, Narendra Modi appears to be in pole place to return as Prime Minister for a 3rd time period. This, nonetheless, doesn’t imply the BJP is invincible, or that it faces no challenges. Indian politics is just too advanced to present anyone get together such a clear or unencumbered walkover.
Why vote share issues
So far as arithmetic goes, it turns into necessary to take a look at vote share. Although the Congress misplaced in three Hindi heartland States, it made greater its vote share in Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh by 1 per cent, shedding out solely in Chhattisgarh. Sanjay Kumar, Professor and Co-Director of Lokniti, a analysis programme run by the Centre for the Research of Growing Societies, mentioned the BJP, compared, made greater leaps: “In Madhya Pradesh, the Congress acquired virtually 41 per cent of the vote, however the BJP acquired 49 per cent. The BJP has added 7-8 per cent extra votes. That’s the story even in Rajasthan.” In Chhattisgarh, the Congress’s vote share went down from 43 to 42 per cent, however votes for the BJP noticed a 13 per cent leap within the State. The BJP, it’s clear, is increasing at a time the Congress has discovered it can not.
Additionally Learn | Professional-BJP wave, not anti-Congress, powered 2023 Meeting election outcomes
Given its skinny electoral presence in a number of States, it turns into important to ask if the Congress is a spent drive within the north. “Sure, you’ll be able to say the Congress is completed for the time being, however when you take a look at its vote share, you see that its help base has not been massively eroded in north India—40 per cent will not be a small vote. The one problem is that the Congress’ technique of mobilising voters has turn out to be dated. It has solely acquired them these many votes in the previous few elections, whereas the BJP has been capable of pull extra voters in its favour,” mentioned Kumar.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrives on the BJP headquarters in New Delhi on December 3 to have fun the get together’s victory in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Chhattisgarh.
| Photograph Credit score:
KAMAL SINGH/PTI
In locations the place it’s in direct contest with the Congress, the BJP has a transparent benefit. There have been some Congress victories—Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka and Telangana—however these have been extra exceptions than the rule. The map of India has remodeled within the final 10 years. When the Modi authorities first got here to energy in 2014, the BJP had governments in seven States. In 5 States—Gujarat, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Goa—there was a BJP Chief Minister. By 2018, the BJP was in energy in as many as 22 States, however Meeting elections that 12 months once more redrew the Indian map of allegiances.
Right this moment, the BJP guidelines 12 States all by itself—Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Haryana, Gujarat, Goa, Assam, Tripura, Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh, and now Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh. The get together can be a part of the ruling coalition in 4 States—Maharashtra, Sikkim, Nagaland and Meghalaya. The Congress is in energy in solely three States, and the Aam Aadmi Celebration is available in third on the nationwide footprint checklist with governments in Delhi and Punjab. The BJP faces a far larger problem from regional events—the Trinamool Congress, the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, even Naveen Patnaik’s Biju Janata Dal in Odisha. The Congress is definitely its weakest challenger.
What BJP acquired proper
There’s a lot that the BJP has finished proper in the case of points and electoral technique. For one, the concentrate on welfare and ladies has been a key determinant within the BJP’s success, each within the States and on the Centre. Shivraj Singh Chouhan, for example, launched a collection of women-centric schemes. ‘Ladli Behna Yojana’ gave monetary help to girls. By making certain 50 per cent reservation for girls in civic elections, and 30 per cent in police recruitment, Chouhan confirmed he had understood the facility of ladies voters. Girls have additionally been an important voters for different events throughout States, from Bihar to Karnataka.
BJP supporters collect at Gun Park in Hyderabad on September 24 to have fun the progress of the Girls’s Reservation Invoice in Parliament.
| Photograph Credit score:
RAMAKRISHNA G/THE HINDU
Neelanjan Sircar, Senior Fellow on the Centre for Coverage Analysis, believes the ladies demographic has turn out to be key to BJP’s successes: “Narendra Modi is extremely well-liked amongst girls voters within the Hindi belt, and these are locations the place the virtually decade-long funding of the BJP is now actually beginning to repay. It might have simply began with gasoline cylinders, however that connection is now beginning to yield outcomes.”
Election Fee knowledge present that 67.2 per cent of Indian girls voted within the 2019 normal election, as towards 46.6 per cent in 1962. When in comparison with males, this was the primary time extra girls had voted in a normal election. The turnout of ladies voters is anticipated to go up even additional in 2024. Since 2014, the Modi authorities has persistently focused this bloc with schemes like Ujjwala, Mudra, and so forth.
Additionally Learn | Modi’s heartland sweep a warning signal for complacent Congress
The Girls’s Reservation Invoice, handed in September, has given the BJP one other edifice from the place it will possibly mission itself as a champion of ladies’s welfare. It doesn’t matter that 33 per cent reservation for girls in Parliament and State legislatures might take over a decade to materialise. The Congress, too, tried catering to this bloc in Karnataka, the place a month-to-month stipend for girls was one of many 5 main ensures it promised. Ashok Gehlot tried one thing comparable in Rajasthan, however his announcement got here solely months earlier than the election. The little he was giving additionally got here too late.
Helped by the truth that it has most mainstream media—tv channels, particularly—on its aspect, the BJP has efficiently created a optimistic narrative about itself. This was how “pro-incumbency” concepts not too long ago gained floor in Madhya Pradesh. Whereas the Congress has not retained a single State since 2014, the BJP has been re-elected in a number of—Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Assam, Uttarakhand, and Gujarat. Higher at booth-level organisation, the BJP is continually pushing the message of optimistic improvement via its schemes and in addition its trump card, Narendra Modi.
Sircar mentioned it was this branding that fuelled the BJP’s return to energy in a number of States. “What model do you affiliate with the Congress? Model Modi could be very particular. It has so much to do with ground-level cadre and their means to promote the Modi model. They’re excellent at constant messaging. Jagan [Mohan Reddy] does it in Andhra Pradesh, and Mamata [Banerjee] in West Bengal, however, no, that is actually not a Congress trait.”
Flags and banners of the BJP are ferried to Chevella, Telangana, the place Residence Minister Amit Shah addressed a public assembly on April 23.
| Photograph Credit score:
NAGARA GOPAL/THE HINDU
The BJP has been fast to counter the Congress’ welfare guarantees with what it calls the “Modi ki assure”. The Prime Minister is probably probably the most essential issue working within the BJP’s favour. Latest State elections sidelined native leaders much more, making Modi the clear face of the get together. It made clear to voters {that a} vote for the BJP was a vote for Modi.
Additionally Learn | How BJP’s aggressive marketing campaign exploited Congress’ weaknesses to safe decisive victory in Rajasthan
Sanjay Kumar of Lokniti mentioned, “If the BJP had determined to contest the elections with a chief-ministerial face, they’d not have finished as effectively. Our survey reveals that 20 per cent of the BJP’s vote got here within the identify of Prime Minister Modi. Persons are appreciating the work of the Central authorities.” That is additionally why private assaults on the Prime Minister and his credibility usually fail. The Adani subject has gained little or no traction with voters, very like the Rafale jet deal controversy in 2019.
The Hindutva issue
The Hindutva issue complicates issues. Some studies from States within the Hindi heartland recommend that controversies just like the Sanatana Dharma row price the Congress get together. Kamal Nath continually performed the ‘Hindutva lite’ card in Madhya Pradesh, at one level even suggesting that India was a “Hindu Rashtra”. Amit Shah, too, promised voters a free darshan on the Ram mandir in his marketing campaign speeches, however these entreaties, it will definitely grew to become clear, didn’t work in Telangana. One dimension by no means does match all. Although heavy on Hindutva rhetoric, the BJP’s marketing campaign in Karnataka failed. The extent of Hindutva’s affect on politics is typically tough to gauge, however in an more and more polarised surroundings, it has turn out to be clear that the area for centrist politics appears to be shrinking in giant elements of the nation.
Congress supporters in Bikaner have fun their get together’s win within the Karnataka Meeting elections on Might 13.
| Photograph Credit score:
PTI
Second of reckoning
The Congress and the opposition have arrived at a second of reckoning. Feeling overconfident after profitable Karnataka, the Congress ignored its allies within the INDIA bloc for 3 months. Had it finished effectively in State elections, the get together might have pushed for a larger say in seat-sharing plans for subsequent 12 months’s normal election, but it surely now appears sure it will be unable to dictate phrases. The knives have been out even on December 3, the day outcomes for 4 States have been introduced. Events just like the JD(U), Shiv Sena, CPI(M) and Nationwide Convention, all took potshots on the Congress. As the one get together within the opposition with a pan-India presence, the Congress is in a direct contest with the BJP in 180-odd Lok Sabha seats. For the opposition to do effectively, the Congress should do effectively, too.
Additionally Learn | Congress’ ready recreation over State elections threatens INDIA bloc’s probabilities in 2024
Congress victories in Karnataka, Telangana and Himachal Pradesh present that when the get together provides a free hand to native leaders, it really challenges its opponent. The get together managed factionalism extra seamlessly in Karnataka than in Rajasthan, making a profitable narrative about corruption within the BJP authorities. In Telangana, regardless of murmurs, Revanth Reddy was given cost, together with Sunil Kanulgolu, the ballot strategist chargeable for Congress’ Karnataka marketing campaign. It’s maybe telling that the Congress’ Madhya Pradesh management was averse to Kanugolu’s recommendation and had turned him away. The Congress management in Delhi seems to be plagued with unhealthy advisers, lots of whom have by no means gained a Lok Sabha election.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee addresses a joint press convention in Bengaluru on July 18, the place 27 opposition events got here collectively to kind a bloc known as INDIA (Indian Nationwide Developmental Inclusive Alliance).
| Photograph Credit score:
SHAILENDRA BHOJAK/PTI
The opposition, although, has but extra to fret about. The difficulty of a caste census appears to have failed amongst voters. In three States—Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh—OBCs have sided with the BJP in giant numbers. “Individuals will help a caste census but it surely gained’t form their voting choices”, mentioned Kumar. “They wish to understand how they are going to profit from a caste census. Communication is essential, however the Congress fails in that regard. They should clarify how a caste census will impression training, prospects of a job, and so forth. Having a caste census alone doesn’t convey something to the individuals.”
Going into 2024, the INDIA bloc lacks a reputable chief who will tackle Modi. The BJP’s success hinges on the Prime Minister, particularly as elections turn out to be pushed by persona. The BJP is aware of effectively the planks it’ll relaxation on in 2024—Modi, hyper-nationalism, Hindutva and welfare. To problem this formidable technique, the opposition must arrive at a story that feels equally persuasive. An more and more aspirational India needs options and supply. Assembly this demand would be the actual problem in 2024, and in addition past.
Nidhi Razdan is a journalist, previously with NDTV. She is a columnist with Gulf Information, and is a Professor of Observe at IILM College, Delhi.
