‘Polarisation is non permanent’: Anand Shrivastava
Anand Shrivastava, Affiliate Professor, Azim Premji College, Bangalore.
| Picture Credit score: By Particular Association
Anand Shrivastava, Affiliate Professor of Economics at Azim Premji College, is the co-author of a analysis paper titled “Spiritual riots and electoral politics in India”, printed within the Journal of Improvement Economics in 2018. Primarily based on information from 16 States from 1981 to 2001, the research exhibits that the BJP’s vote share elevated by 5 share factors on common in elections held a 12 months following a communal violence.
Excerpts:
Your research means that the BJP carried out higher in elections following communal clashes. How lengthy has this sample been at play?
Our research seems to be on the impact of communal riots on the BJP’s vote share in Meeting elections from 1981 to 2001. The connection between communal clashes and electoral politics might be seen simply earlier than the primary basic election in 1951 when the Bharatiya Jana Sangh was shaped. Though its vote share normally elections grew from 3 per cent in 1951 to 14 per cent in 1971, we’ve got not analysed the impact of riots throughout this era.
What have been the explanations for the riots?
The information on riots that we used have been first put collectively by Ashutosh Varshney and Steve Wilkinson utilizing reviews of riots within the Instances of India. We prolonged this information to the timeframe of our research. The proximate causes for riots given in these reviews are fairly different and embrace riots occurring as responses to different incidents, together with earlier riots. A big share of reviews is about pageant actions, like processions, being the trigger. We discovered that within the years when an necessary Hindu pageant in a State fell on a Friday, the holy day for Muslims, the possibilities of a riot being reported doubled.
Does the influence of communal pressure stay solely in a specific space?
Our evaluation is finished at a district stage. We discovered that the incidence of riots in a single district had results on the electoral end result of constituencies not solely throughout the district however in neighbouring districts as nicely. It’s unlikely that localised communal tensions might help win a complete State except the election is a detailed one.
Additionally Learn | What’s behind the communal clashes in Maharashtra?
Do you suppose the voters are trapped into communal politics?
We discovered that the vote share of BJP elevated by 5 per cent on common in constituencies that have been in the identical district the place the riot passed off. This will likely or is probably not sufficient to vary the general outcome within the State. Different work, by Steve Wilkinson and Saumitra Jha in Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat, respectively, has discovered that communal clashes are extra possible when elections are shut and aggressive.
An necessary discovering of our research was that this polarisation is non permanent. Past a 12 months, the riots don’t appear to have any important impact on elections. Therefore, the thought of voters being completely trapped in non secular polarisation is probably not appropriate.
Within the latest Karnataka election, communal politics appeared to have zero influence on the result. Are Indian voters wising as much as the political agenda behind communal tensions?
I don’t suppose that voters are unaware that there might be political motivations behind communal tensions.
Folks’s causes to vote are different and sophisticated. In my opinion, the outcomes of 1 election don’t point out a change within the social realities on the bottom. Simply because the success of the BSP and the election of Mayawati as Chief Minister in UP didn’t imply that caste hierarchies in society had been upended, the BJP’s loss in Karnataka doesn’t imply that communal fault traces in society have healed and won’t be used for political positive aspects in future elections.
Do you see an identical disturbing development of social tensions throughout India forward of the overall election in 2024?
I’ve not analysed the latest elections and riots since our research interval resulted in 2001. Going by my very own, admittedly biased, studying of the previous few election years, I believe it’s possible that there will likely be some incidents, particularly in States the place the BJP is intently matched by the opposition.
